Book of the Month: The Mysterious Case of the Stone of Destiny

Book review of The Mysterious Case of the Stone of Destiny by David Maule

Review by Duncan Black, TDC Volunteer 

This book is not a novel, but a genuine attempt to answer a question long asked about the Stone of Destiny, or Stone of Scone (or Jacob’s pillow); the coronation stone of Scottish monarchs from before the creation of the Kingdom of Alba. The stone that was stolen by Edward the first of England in 1296…or was it?

David Maule’s book is an excellent read and he presents the evidence, quotes the witnesses, identifies the probable suspects and presents his conclusions as if it were a court case, which makes for gripping reading.

If you are interested in the period of the Scottish Wars of Independence, especially the First War of Independence from 1296 to 1328, and the colourful characters (suspects?) who fought, betrayed, sought to be king, changed sides and eventually achieved Scottish independence, this is a book for you.

The research is detailed, and the logic he applies to his investigation is clear and easy to follow. Is the Stone of Destiny that currently sits in Perth Museum and was recently used in the coronation of King Charles III, the original stone? The stone that Fergus, son of Erc, the first King of Scots took from Ireland to Argyll?

Read David Maule’s entertaining evidence and conclusions and make up your own mind.